Roger Waters - Shine On You Crazy Diamond

Pink Floyd

Waters May have been the creative force in the writing, but David Gilmour was clearly the musician of the Pink Floyd. Gilmore's performances of the same songs are infinitely better in my opinion.
Cesar Cestari
It's amazing to see how important Gilmour is for this hit... It's still good, of course.
henri best
Wow this is not at all good without Gilmour.
Joe N
...great pink floyd cover band.
Hector Martinez
This is good! But Gilmore nails it
Luca Marrocu
Inascoltabile. Un capolavoro deturpato. Waters é un grande paroliere, ma shine on senza Gilmour é semplicemente impossibile. La sua chitarra inarrivabile e la sua voce unica.
Jose Onorio
...roger es el creado de muchas letras de pink floyd,david evidentemente es el alma que manifiesta la esencia de pink ployd-
Syd Barrett said he wanted a band with 2 saxophone players a and a female backing band.. in 1968, to pink floyd, and they say he was crazy,, go figure..:)
Pinky Floyd
HD PinkFlotd you are the best ....the hell with copyright
In all fairness - Waters sang pretty flipping well back in the 60's and 70's (untrained but pure effect and emotion and could better hold a key back then) He also used to play a mean bass. His singing and playing did not age well. Gilmour was / is, a more schooled and learned musician - perhaps. Waters was the dark / grit vocally and Gilmour would "lift us up" with his voice. If you watch this whole performance though - Waters still has a few nice vocal moments. Again, just pure drive likely more than raw talent. He used to be a machine lol
Fernando Gabriel
Roger ❤
Is that a metronome throughout the song?
Jesse Lee Barnes
It was an amazing and spiritual experience. One of the best concerts I have ever been to.
Boxing Talk
•Post-waters pink floyd : crippled •Post-pink floyd waters: crippled
Manuela Gil
turuntash the boo
Fernanda Silva
Vivaaaaaaa Roger Waters.🤘🤘🤘🤘
x x
Sadly, Waters is the weak link in the performance of this cover version.
Keyboard player playing too fast, he is not in the music
Te amo Roger Waters 😊
Alireza Ebneshahidi
I never get tired listening to this song.
Juan Pablo González
I think roger should stick to singing songs that he has originally sung. Song
Chris B
Oh dear oh dear, I've heard better pub band covers, terrible.
Slaf Sales
me desculpem os fãs de Roger waters, essa música ai só David Gilmour pra cantar e tocar, não tirando o mérito de Waters excelente compositor... mas essa música só Gilmour... bom minha opinião. sei que cada um tem a sua e respeito isso.
r hartnett
I've always love listening to this song, it is so soothing and calming. Beautiful!  :)
Sidnei Mota
Apesar de Waters ser o pai da criança a versão de Gilmor é muito melhor
Aldo Perez
<3 uff prro :v
Damond ! :)
Leszek Byrski
Roger coling from !!!
Janice Place
infinite......i thought it was, " Diamond", ?
Dork of Cork
What a fantastic piece of music !
Alex Aisorp
Perfect sincro audio video !!!
Divya Pal Singh
"Like two black holes in the sky". Roger Waters poet extraordinaire, next year's Nobel Prize in Literature, emulating Bob Dylan?
Jean Marie Lagrave
Mon groupe préféré. superbe époque
Pedro Leon Icarus
Even I can play this guitar better, cmon wtf dude
Mustafa Can Kaya
i love roger but his singing makes me wanna go to the kitchen and put a knife through my throat!
Hugo Justiniano
Buena versión, buenos arreglos, hermosa melodía....
Pink Floyd the Best gilmour rick y nick
Assim se vê a importância do David nos Pink Floyd!!! David the best!!!
Miroslav Horvat
where is Bramhal junior ??..much better choise for lead guitar...
pedro mello
Horrivel, Roger Waters não serve pra cantar em tom auto, mesmo sendo a voz dele na gravação original
Jesús Rosales Reyna
For those of you commenting on Gilmour's performances being better, please let me know how many times you've seen both perform live so we can have a talk, I'm available anytime and beer is on me. Having seen these two legends twice each and I'm up for a third time with Roger in the next month, I think my opinion is fairly objective.
João Gomes
Simply fantastic
celio salahudin yasuf silva salahudin yasuf
tem 40 imbecil porra vai ouvir ANITA QUIME VAI VAI PR APUTA K PARIU..
TJ Gamache
only thing i do not like is how quick they do the instrumental.... but a fantastic song nonetheless
София Дмитрук
Космос! Вселенная! Вечная музыка.Браво!
Dani Canga
La mejor de los mejores.
Shine on ... Roger Waters - Shine On You Crazy Diamond 😊😋😍💜👌👍♥️
Esto es en el Desert Trip?
oops, you skipped the best beginning part. 0 point.
Bryan Wiedemann
shine oooonn you craaazy baaarreeettt...
rock roll
yes I love this song allways a pleasure to hear the words and music just connects me back respect to pink Floyd .
olindo pereira dicosilva
show sou fã numero 1 the best walters
Maria Madalena Alves Farias Murino
Tommaso Di Lillo
Gilmour is missing
Tutte le volte che ascolto questo pezzo mi vengono i brividi, mitici, peccato si siano sciolti.
Antonio Carlos Acioli Silva
Só coisas boas.
cris tofer
lo mejor
Pam J Pollick
best g damned band on the planet, minus whoever or however many. May your gods keep you on an everlasting trip, SydB, and, by the way, Rogers Pink.
Giuseppe Aprile
Da brividi
Good Roger ! His version is more expressive and full of love !
Sheldon F
do these women know who they are singing about?  I hope so.  Rest in peace, Sid.  You were truly the  best.
Jose Assunção
Omg terrible
Own private I dunno
Aufhebung! Water and Gilmour barely able to restrain their mutual antipathy. Creative friction of which we are the beneficiaries. (Rick Wright getting a credit, why? because ...he was simply there at the time, or maybe his reserve kept things a bit civilised, or maybe the key protagonists felt bad about the damaging effect of their behaviour on him?)
OMG - his voice is a shame for this song
Eliso Akhaladze
Steve Frost
all style and no substance. go and see David or Brit Floyd, a much better show
Lauro Moreira da Silva
Joe Cool
now there are 2 Pink Floyds ? David Gilmore and Roger Waters ?
Sara Heart
Paul Daino
Great singer
Alaeddine Mahboub
Hello.the pink floyd is syd barret and roger waters nick masson wright.........and guilmour.
Dario Lo Porto
Now.. i can die
gilmour y Rick mejor k Waters muxo mejores músicos
Alessandro Mello
non capisco certi commenti, waters, che pure non è il mio ideale di simpatia, ha sempre legittimamente portato in tour i capolavori dei pink floyd, con chitarristi mi sembra più che degni, ma ovviamente ci si concentra più sulla canzone. oer alcune ha riservato arrangiamenti molto liberi, interessanti, e meno male.
Evgene Yakovlev
он тоже вслед за Гилмором эту песню играет?
Arthur Phillips
I remember when I was young - I shone like a satellite in orbit around a star of cheese which briefly broke the orbit and caused ripples in the fabric of space time - that was the late 80's second summer of love - techno acid drugs revolution - did it actually happen though? no, still in an orbit around a star of cheese so it didn't happen, don't say it did coz it didn't so that's that, hello cheese.
Mark Eldred
Eww. Having just listened to a bunch of David Gilmour's songs, this doesn't come close to measuring up.
Alessandro Mello
Birdie Nam
This sucks. But it is still better than his understanding of what is going on in the Middle East.
For all those nuthugging gilmour, you oafs should know Roger sang the song on the record
Carrasco Hernández.
Las Mejores Canciones de Roger Waters \m/
Michael Heron
what a load of tosh, who does waters think he is kidding. There are many tribute bands out there who do it far better. Try using a fender strat boys.
Jesús Rosales Reyna
Roger's version is infinitely better than Gilmour's, not only he is the singer on the record, but he was indeed the creative one in Pink Floyd, and all the deets that came in production of The Wall and The Dark Side of the Moon albums, came from Waters' head, besides, overall not only he's a better and more complete artist, he's also a better human being, Gilmour is such an asshole in terms of personal beliefs.